id,case_id,role,surname,forename,occupation,place_id,raw_segment,seq 4156177,2080235,plaintiff,Makefeld,Giles,,,"Makefeld, Giles",0 4156178,2080235,defendant,Springold,William,shipmaster,609752,"Springold, William, of Beeston, shipmaster",0 4156179,2080235,defendant,Springold,Robert,,609752,"Springold, Robert, of Beeston, sailor",1