id,case_id,role,surname,forename,occupation,place_id,raw_segment,seq 4310902,2133963,plaintiff,Bowen,John,,,"Bowen, John",0 4310903,2133963,defendant,Vaughan,John,gent,630980,"Vaughan, John, of Clonne, gent",0 4310904,2133963,defendant,Vaughan,Thomas,,630980,"Vaughan, Thomas, of Clonne, gent, his son",1