id,case_id,role,surname,forename,occupation,place_id,raw_segment,seq 4740636,2277779,plaintiff,Bate,Robert,,592075,"Bate, Robert, of Tomworth",0 4740637,2277779,plaintiff,Bate,John,son of Robert Bate,,"Bate, John, son of Robert Bate",1 4740638,2277779,defendant,Vale,Thomas,butcher,585869,"Vale, Thomas, of London, butcher",0